Connect with us


IAS edge proves a winner as chief secretaries overshadow political bosses in virus battle




Tamil Nadu Disaster Response Force personnel conduct a lockdown awareness drive in Chennai last week | Representational image | PTI
Tamil Nadu Disaster Response Force personnel conduct a lockdown awareness drive in Chennai last week | Representational image | PTI

Text Size:

New Delhi: From Tamil Nadu to West Bengal and Bihar, the top IAS officers across states are shattering the hierarchy of governance as they have become the centre of all decision-making in the fight against Covid-19

With the urgency of the pandemic necessitating the elimination of procedures to speed up decisions, the chief secretaries of states are taking the lead over MPs, MLAs, and even ministers, in the administrative response to C0vid-19, and reporting directly to chief ministers. 

The office of the chief secretary is the highest administrative position in states, and they serve as the apex coordinators of all departments.

Equivalent to the rank of secretaries in the central government, the office of the chief secretary is the ultimate position an IAS officer can rise to in states — a position that has come to wield even more power and influence since the country was locked down on account of the Covid-19 pandemic.

Sample this: At a televised meeting of West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee and Chief Secretary Rajiva Sinha last week with industry chambers and representatives from micro, small and medium enterprises (MSMEs), the chief secretary said a proposal made by the industry representatives could be sent to the MSME secretary. However, CM Mamata Banerjee immediately weighed in and said the proposal should only come to the chief secretary.

In Tamil Nadu, Chief Secretary K. Shanmugam was credited with mounting a quick response to the pandemic. Within 10 days of the state diagnosing its first Covid-19 case on 7 March, the chief secretary had issued an elaborate set of instructions to all government departments and institutes, and called for the constitution of ‘contact tracing teams’ in districts, procurement of personal protective equipment (PPE), use of thermal scanners at entry and exit points of railway stations, and setting up of helplines, among other measures. This, even before the second case was reported on 19 March.

Now, the state administration is being lauded for having among the lowest Covid-19 death rates despite accounting for the third highest number of cases.

Also Read: How India’s young IAS officers ensured a smooth lockdown in every corner of the country

‘An administrative, not political, crisis’

Officers of the Indian Administrative Service (IAS), chief secretaries, on average, gather 30 years’ experience in pure administration before rising to the post. However, even as the top-most officers of the state, they are subordinate to the political class.

Speaking to ThePrint, several senior IAS officers said the new turn in the role was in stark contrast to ordinary times, when a chief secretary’s job is largely limited to grievance redressal, transfers and postings, with most files being approved by different ministers, before they ultimately go to the chief minister. 

“Sometimes, the chief secretary would not even know something was being done until the very last moment,” said a senior IAS officer from Punjab.

The Covid-19 pandemic seems to have altered this convention, even if temporarily. This, officers say, is because even politicians realise that administrative acumen is a greater asset in such a crisis.

“What the country needs right now is administrative and not political acumen, and the bureaucracy is way more well-versed with that than the politicians… So, obviously, it is they who are at the forefront,” said an IAS officer from West Bengal. 

“Covid-19 is an administrative, not political, crisis, that’s why you see the predominance of the bureaucracy in every sphere.”

The aforementioned IAS officer from Punjab explained that a crisis of current proportions required quick decisions.

“Generally, all decision-making is based on long-established and lengthy protocols — approvals need to be sought from the ministers, files travel from all levels,” said the officer. 

“Now, we don’t have the luxury of time…We need quick coordination among all departments, and there is no time for approval from ministers.” 

Covid-19, the officer said, “is not just a health crisis, it is a crisis that requires constant inter-departmental coordination – food distribution, procurement of medical equipment, handling migrations, enforcing a curfew…” 

“In such a time, it is not and cannot be business as usual. Departments and ministries cannot be working in silos with each secretary reporting to their minister,” the officer added.

This is why, the officer said, “the chief secretary… has become the central point of all decision-making because it is the job of the chief secretary to ensure coordination as the head of the state cabinet secretariat…” 

“It is just that, in ordinary times, this level of coordination is not always needed,” the officer added.

It is, however, not just inter-departmental coordination within states for which the chief secretary has emerged as the fulcrum. 

A senior officer from Tamil Nadu said the chief secretary had become the “one-point contact” between the central government and states too. 

“All executive meetings held by the union home secretary or the cabinet secretary involve chief secretaries…There is absolute centralisation of power in the chief secretary’s office, which is not only unavoidable, but necessary,” the officer added.

There are no proposals these days — just execution by the state administration, which is headed by the chief secretary, the officer added. “Earlier, all administrative decisions would be vetted by the Chief Minister’s Office (CMO), now that does not happen — it cannot,” the officer said. “The chief ministers are also not interfering…Since it is a crisis situation, approval from the political executive is seen to be a given.”

Also Read: No discussing Bhilwara model with media, IAS officer Rajendra Bhatt in letter to officials

‘Stamp of safety’

While the constant need for coordination among departments is one reason, there is another less obvious reason why every decision is being routed through chief secretaries, added the officer from Punjab. All secretaries and senior officers, the officer said, felt safer if a decision had the chief secretary’s stamp.

“For example, in Punjab, there was a decision on testing kits that was taken… It was seen as a hyper-technical decision, so the chief secretary was not involved,” the officer said. “But when there was a problem, the chief secretary had to come to the rescue for damage control.”

In Bihar, an official said the role of ministers, in particular, had become negligible. All the business is being carried out by secretaries in their departments, who are reporting to the chief secretary, who is ultimately reporting to the chief minister, the officer said.

It helps that the lockdown has been invoked under the National Disaster Management Act and the Epidemic Act, which empower the administration to call the shots during the crisis, an officer from West Bengal said. “So, in that sense, the orders of the chief secretary have statutory backing.”

In the current scheme of things, it is not just the chief secretary, but the entire administrative framework or the bureaucracy that has become all-powerful, the officer added. “You see, the politicians — the MPs and the MLAs are all indoors…” the officer said. “Politics has taken a backseat.”

With inputs from Madhuparna Das

Also Read: Modi govt now plans to rank ministries on how they implement direct benefit transfer scheme


ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.


Andhra doctor, suspended for alleging PPE shortage, now beaten by cops for ‘creating nuisance’




doctor with a stethoscope
A doctor with a stethoscope (Representative image) | Pixabay

Text Size:

Bengaluru: A doctor with a government hospital in Andhra Pradesh, who was suspended for questioning the shortage of PPE kits, was admitted to a mental health facility Sunday, a day after he was allegedly manhandled by the police and arrested for creating nuisance in Visakhapatnam.

Dr Sudhakar Rao, a government civil surgeon, was beaten, his hands tied behind his back and dragged by police officers Sunday. During the incident, Sudhakar allegedly verbally abused the Jagan Mohan Reddy government in an inebriated state. Videos of the incident have since been widely shared online.

“The police control room received a call about a person creating nuisance on Beach Road Hospital in Visakhapatnam. The Fourth Town police was rushed there and found that the person was the suspended doctor, Sudhakar.

“When the police tried to control him, he snatched the mobile phone of an officer and threw it away. He is suffering from mental disorder and he was drunk. He was sent for a medical examination,” Vishakapatnam Police Commissioner R.K. Meena told the media Sunday.

Sudhakar was admitted to a mental hospital Sunday after doctors at the King George Hospital in Vishakapatnam said he suffered from anxiety.

“Since the doctor is in anxiety and talking irrelevant things, I have referred him to a mental care hospital in Visakhapatnam,” said Dr Radha Rani, medical superintendent, King George Hospital.

A statement released by the hospital said: “Dr Sudhakar was brought to the KGH casualty ward at 6.30 pm. From the smell, it was found that he was in a drunk condition. Under the influence of alcohol, he did not cooperate with anybody there and kept abusing all. Still, his pulse, BP were checked. Pulse was 98, BP 140/100. Blood samples were sent to forensic lab to ascertain alcohol content in his blood.”

Also read: 6 toilets for 20 houses, inadequate testing: Why Mumbai’s Worli chawls are a Covid hotspot

‘Treatment towards Sudhakar was inhuman’

Sudhakar, who spent more than 10 years at the Narsipatnam Government Hospital in Andhra Pradesh, was suspended from his duties in March after he openly criticised the Reddy government for failing to provide PPE kits and N95 masks to doctors treating Covid-19 patients.

He had alleged that the state government was giving N95 masks and PPE kits meant for doctors to politicians and the police.

A video of Sudhakar criticising the government was also shared widely. In the clip, he can be heard saying: “We are putting our lives at risk here. We are asked to use the same mask for 15 days and a fresh mask will be provided only twice a month.”

Speaking to ThePrint, Dr P. Gangadhar Rao, member of the National COVID Committee of the Indian Medical Association, said the manner in which Sudhakar was manhandled by the police was “inhuman” and “violated” human rights.

“We strongly condemn the way he was taken into custody. He was not carrying a weapon, he was alone, the number of policemen outnumbered him. Why treat him like that? We also saw a video where a policeman beats him with a lathi,” said Dr Gangadhar.

He added that Rao was one of the most experienced anaesthetists the Andhra Pradesh government had.

“Our next step of action is to get Sudhakar to write an unconditional apology for having used filthy language, abusing the chief minister and the government. We will then take our appeal to the CM seeking that he be reinstated,” Gangadhar said.

Also read: Face shields, gowns, masks — the new attire for cabin crew post lockdown


ThePrint is now on Telegram. For the best reports & opinion on politics, governance and more, subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram.

Subscribe to our YouTube channel.

Continue Reading