Connect with us


Prey: Immigration, Islam and the Erosion of Women’s Legal rights by Ayaan Hirsi Ali assessment




Prey: Immigration, Islam and the Erosion of Women’s Rights by Ayaan Hirsi Ali review

yaan Hirsi Ali is a Somali-born critic of Islam and Islamism.

In 2004, she turned identified internationally soon after Dutch director Theo van Gogh was murdered for a shorter film she had published called Submission on women’s subservient standing in Islam. The Islamist who murdered him, threatened that she would be next.

In 2006, Hirsi Ali co-signed a Manifesto in opposition to Islamism, which pressured that the struggle against this new totalitarianism was ‘not a clash of civilisations’ involving West and East, but a struggle concerning democrats and theocrats the world over.

The rise of the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain and the ex-Muslim motion in the West, defending the suitable to depart and criticise Islam with no dread, intended that her work was appropriate to a lot of. She left the Netherlands to be a part of a conservative assume tank in the US shortly after a controversy over her Dutch citizenship and has been there at any time because.

The premise of Hirsi Ali’s new guide Prey: Immigration, Islam and the Erosion of Women’s Rights is that there is, in actuality, a clash of civilisations and that the rise in sexual violence in Europe because 2015 is owing to an improve of migrant gentlemen from Muslim-majority nations around the world with sexist attitudes.

She says the British grooming gangs illustrate ‘the persistence of misogynistic attitudes in immigrant Muslim communities.’ She provides that ‘increasing quantities of Pakistani-British males have turn into included in criminal offense considering the fact that the 2000s’ in the United kingdom and that there have been ‘significant will increase [in sexual violence offences] in a number of areas and countries (England, Wales, Denmark, Sweden) right after 2015, which definitely can not be stated away by technicalities.’

Undoubtedly, sexual violence is pervasive and on the rise in the United kingdom, Europe and everywhere. For instance, incidents of rape per 100,000 are increased in Australia and the US than a the greater part of European countries. According to WHO, most sexual violence is carried out by an personal partner, not a stranger. This violence has been enormously exacerbated for the duration of lockdown.

Despite the quantities, violence from ladies is disregarded not simply because of ‘political correctness’ as Hirsi Ali states, but due to the fact it is hardly taken significantly – no make any difference who commits the criminal offense.

Discriminatory rape legislation, weak enforcement, absence of investigations and prosecutions, small reporting of rape thanks to distrust, austerity measures shrinking entry to justice, lenient sentencing, sufferer blaming, and restricted consent-based legislation are some of the reasons that perpetrators – whether they are grooming gangs, wolf-pack rapists or clergymen – do not experience justice.

The prevalent denominator of the sexual violence pandemic is not men from Muslim-greater part international locations but adult men who dedicate sexual violence and the states that fall short, yet again and once more, to hold them to account.

Nonetheless, Hirsi Ali insists there a causal relationship among elevated migration and elevated sexual violence. To clearly show this, she depends on stats she herself admits are ‘fraught with difficulty’ even though also acknowledging that police in most European nations around the world, including the British isles, do not document perpetrator migration standing or faith.

In purchase to clearly show how migrant adult males from Muslim-majority nations around the world are unique from what she phone calls the indigenous-born, she places them in the four groups of: adapters (whom she claims are ‘a minority’), menacing sorts, fanatics, and coasters (people presumably on welfare). For her, a ‘plausible rationalization for the apparent adaption deficit is the mindset of Muslim migrants toward women.’ And by Muslim migrants, she signifies ‘new arrivals trying to get asylum’ and ‘the sons and even grandsons of immigrants.’

But sexism is not in someone’s DNA mainly because of a lottery of start. All those in power decide the dominant tradition and use drive to impose it, consequently why many flee. Also, no group, population or culture are monoliths. Culture is not static. It is regularly shifting and currently being revised, reviewed and challenged by folks with company. In Iran, for case in point, there is a tsunami of atheism and a vibrant women’s liberation movement irrespective of a repressive theocracy.

This is not to say that migrants are collectively very good just as they are not collectively negative. Nor are all beliefs and cultural techniques equal or equally valid. But it is people who dedicate crimes that ought to be prosecuted and held accountable for sexual violence. Regardless of whether they are Muslim, ex-Muslim or Christian. Jewish, Hindu, atheist or Buddhist. Regardless of whether they are citizens or new arrivals. Whether or not they are documented or undocumented. Guilt by association and the putting of collective blame on migrant adult males from Muslim-the greater part countries, on the other hand, are tribalistic with no put in a fashionable justice process.

For a person enamoured with ‘Western civilisation,’ Hirsi Ali ought to fully grasp particular person rather than group accountability for crime. Her emphasis on migrant adult men from Muslim-bulk nations around the world indicates that her alternatives are focused on migration regulate alternatively than ending sexual violence. They incorporate severe punishments for small infractions, improved southern border safety, enlarged defence budgets, expanded surveillance, and further more armed service interventions as properly as the scrapping of the asylum regime and the deportation of people who really don’t subscribe to or adopt western values. Which ‘western values’ is unclear: hers, Douglas Murray’s, Donald Trump’s and Tommy Robinson’s, or that of Martin Luther King, Emmeline Pankhurst and the Tolpuddle Martyrs.

She also endorses that welfare be linked to conduct and that migrants be screened, together with by a psychologist, for their ‘ability to adapt.’ She doesn’t feel worried about what will happen to freedoms of conscience and expression that are the cornerstones of Western – or far more properly, universal – values. Or that linking the ideal to social expert services and asylum to ethically bankrupt ideas of morality are a rehashing of Victorian notions that blame poverty on the lifestyle and character of the so-called undeserving poor.

She finishes her e book as she begins it – with scaremongering: ‘Do we want a Europe in which photographs of woman existence taken before 2015 turn into objects of fascination, like [those] that the central character censors in Atwood’s sequence to the Handmaid’s Tale…?’

Penned during Trump’s presidency, and posted only in the US, Hirsi Ali’s ebook on the Uk and Europe panders to Trumpian and populist politics. It is more anxious with defending the racialisation of crime and the criminalisation of migration than ending sexual violence. Plainly, even if all her options are carried out to the letter, violence from females will still be a pandemic. But that is not, following all, the position of her e book.

Prey: Immigration, Islam and the Erosion of Women’s Legal rights by Ayaan Hirsi Ali (Harper, £20.91)

Maryam Namazie is the Spokesperson of the Council of Ex-Muslims of Britain and One Regulation for All


‘Finding this community is huge’: story of world’s first homosexual rugby group captured on film




‘Finding this community is huge’: story of world’s first gay rugby team captured on film

Eammon Ashton-Atkinson was searching for an fulfilling way to counteract the proverbial Heathrow Injection, the immediate weight acquire that can befall new arrivals in London, when he listened to about the Kings Cross Steelers.

The world’s to start with gay rugby club was fashioned in 1995 by a group of good friends consuming in a pub near the station, and has because develop into a trail-blazing force in LGBTQ rugby, central to a globally network of extra than 70 inclusive golf equipment. Russell Tovey’s boyfriend Steve Brockman is on the staff (he wears rainbow socks for game titles). Now it is the matter of a new documentary, Steelers.

Ashton-Atkinson, an Australian Television set producer who moved listed here at the finish of his twenties, experienced an innate enthusiasm for rugby, but he hadn’t had considerably to do with the match since his schooldays, when he was the goal of vicious homophobic bullying that peaked in sports activities lessons.

“I got known as each title beneath the sunlight to the level wherever I would just go down to the audio area and practise the piano rather,” he remembers.

Fast ahead a 10 years or so, and Ashton-Atkinson reached out to the Steelers, only to understand the squad was oversubscribed. “I observed out in which they ended up teaching and rocked up in any case,” he remembers. “I’m pretty persistent, and when I moved to London I experienced this sense of, it is now or never”.

He was hooked right away. “For people of us who had been excluded from activity at college, who had been instructed we did not belong or designed to really feel not comfortable, obtaining this particular neighborhood in which you go to war with your mates is substantial,” he claims.


Acquiring beforehand struggled with his psychological overall health, Ashton-Atkinson states he benefited enormously from rediscovering rugby with out fearing the intolerance that had marred his childhood activities. In 2018, the workforce was getting ready to travel to Amsterdam to take part in the Bingham Cup — a biannual intercontinental tournament named following Mark Bingham, a gay rugby player who saved life by aiding to end United Flight 93 from reaching its focus on all through the 9/11 attacks — when Ashton-Atkinson endured an damage that would maintain him from playing.

Not information with spectating, he rented some cinema-common machines and established about filming the tour for what would come to be his new documentary, Steelers.

For the film, Ashton-Atkinson turned his digital camera on teammates like Andrew McDowell, an African-Colombian American within centre whose besequinned off-pitch drag persona Drewalicious raises eyebrows between the club’s aged guard, and Welshwoman Nic Evans, the Steelers’ then-director of rugby who talks movingly about her possess activities as a girl navigating the male-dominated earth of rugby, and her tireless devotion to her fees. “I imagine their self esteem is a thin veil more than a deficiency of self-belief,” she problems all through the movie.

Recreation faces: Steelers player Steve Brockman, previously mentioned left, with his boyfriend, Russell Tovey

/ Getty Images

But Ashton-Atkinson states the person who has struck the most resonant chord with audiences is a man who initially didn’t want to take part at all. In contrast to Ashton-Atkinson, 38-calendar year-aged Simon Jones was a rugby insider whose formative decades ended up invested steeped in the tradition of the game.

“My parents lived 30 seconds from Moseley Rugby Club in Birmingham, and I try to remember campaigning for them to get me about the road from a incredibly younger age,” he tells me in excess of Zoom.

A common younger man who “was into anything that was outdoor and sporty”, Jones states he realized that he was homosexual from the age of 10 but feared that his sexuality would upend his “happy” existence. He settled to stay a solitary psychological existence, with the family’s pet canine Rolo his template for uncomplicated devotion to other people. “I always say I dependent my lifetime decisions around a black Labrador,” he jokes in one particular of the film’s most poignant moments.


Jones put in his twenties ascending the occupation ladder in London when enjoying competitively for golf equipment in this article and in Birmingham, devoting every single instant of leisure time to his rugby buddies. He was, he jokes, “the most reliable wingman at Infernos ever”, referring to the Clapham High Avenue nightclub, an infamous den of exuberant twentysomething heterosexuality.

“I definitely imagined that I’d be ready to cope,” Jones tells me. “And then when truth hit, I just shed handle of the circumstance.”

Protracted durations of immobilising melancholy preceded an personal injury that manufactured him re-appraise his foreseeable future in rugby. His subsequent rehabilitation gave him the self esteem to achieve out to Steelers in his early thirties, and his loved ones have been supportive considering that he produced the decision to come out. “Steelers was a lifeline in terms of me becoming in a position to consider what daily life could be like on the other aspect of my isolation,” he suggests.

A handsome, sociable, effective law firm who talks animatedly about his need to enable long run generations of homosexual gamers via his affiliation with Steelers, Jones is the first to accept how incongruous it looks that somebody like him living in 21st century London ought to have had to continue to be closeted for so very long. It would have aided enormously, he states, experienced there been prominent illustrations of openly homosexual players at the very top of the match he liked.


Of pioneers these as Gareth Thomas, the former Wales global who designed heritage by coming out to the close of his profession in 2009, Jones says: “They are surprisingly courageous but it hasn’t been straightforward for them — they’ve endured substantial emotional turmoil and sacrifice.

“For all the progress, we’re evidently however not in a location where folks can just breeze by means of remaining by themselves, and I’m truly searching ahead to that working day.”

Ashton-Atkinson’s film only begun to consider form a 12 months right after the Steelers returned from Amsterdam, when Wallabies star Israel Folau — 1 of the most important names in Australian rugby and a guy with a historical past of homophobic tweeting — took to Instagram with a publish declaring that “Hell Awaits” homosexuals. It led to the termination of his $4 million contract with Rugby Australia.


Reviews like Folau’s “are just stupid and unnecessary, and they lead to actual harm”, states Ashton-Atkinson. LGBT persons are much more possible to encounter mental wellbeing difficulties, homelessness and domestic abuse when when compared with the normal populace.

But the Folau episode did at least supply the impetus for Ashton-Atkinson, who married a Steelers teammate and now lives in Washington DC, to dig out his footage from the Bingham Cup and start out making Steelers the motion picture.

It seems ironic that Folau — who is presently trying a return to the Australian recreation with marketing assistance from the country’s Christian Foyer — ought to have inadvertently presented lifestyle to a movie that’s these types of a persuasive testimony to the energy of inclusive activity. And this week it starts streaming to the international audience it warrants. Wonderful attempt, mate.

Steelers is on Amazon Prime now

Continue Reading